"Overshoot" is a concept that has been debated from when it first been proposed. As a specific term, it goes back to William Catton's 1980 "Overshoot" book, but the idea goes back to earlier works, including "The Limits to Growth" of 1972, with perhaps the first clear and complete description of the idea by Garret Hardin with his 1968 paper titled "The Tragedy of the Commons" (which took the title from a 1823 essay by William Forster Lloyd. Despite being in the human mindsphere for so long, the concept remains controversial to this date. Mainly, it is the result of being irreversibly against the grain of the current economic theories, which normally assume that the mechanisms of the free market lead to the optimization of economic systems. Indeed, the concept of overshot was born outside economics and it is, rather, mutuated from biology. In modern terms, we would say that it belongs to the field of "biodynamics." The debate on overshoot is not just academic as it cuts through the sinews of the very survival of human civilization. There is little or no intermediate position between the "self-healing" vision of economists and the "self-destroying" vision of biodynamicists. The current self healing model of human economic systems is prevalent among decision makers but, if it turns out to be wrong, then humankind goes at full speed toward its own destruction. In the present communication, we do not pretend to be able to prove that the overshoot model is of absolutely general validity, but we can show how some economic systems, namely fisheries and mineral extraction, can be quantitatively described by a simple system dynamics model that has the overshoot character as its basic feature.
Perissi, I., Lavacchi, A., Bardi, U., El Asmar, T. (2016). Overshoot in the exploitation of natural resources as studied by dynamical modeling of fisheries. In Degrowth conference report.
Overshoot in the exploitation of natural resources as studied by dynamical modeling of fisheries
Perissi I;
2016
Abstract
"Overshoot" is a concept that has been debated from when it first been proposed. As a specific term, it goes back to William Catton's 1980 "Overshoot" book, but the idea goes back to earlier works, including "The Limits to Growth" of 1972, with perhaps the first clear and complete description of the idea by Garret Hardin with his 1968 paper titled "The Tragedy of the Commons" (which took the title from a 1823 essay by William Forster Lloyd. Despite being in the human mindsphere for so long, the concept remains controversial to this date. Mainly, it is the result of being irreversibly against the grain of the current economic theories, which normally assume that the mechanisms of the free market lead to the optimization of economic systems. Indeed, the concept of overshot was born outside economics and it is, rather, mutuated from biology. In modern terms, we would say that it belongs to the field of "biodynamics." The debate on overshoot is not just academic as it cuts through the sinews of the very survival of human civilization. There is little or no intermediate position between the "self-healing" vision of economists and the "self-destroying" vision of biodynamicists. The current self healing model of human economic systems is prevalent among decision makers but, if it turns out to be wrong, then humankind goes at full speed toward its own destruction. In the present communication, we do not pretend to be able to prove that the overshoot model is of absolutely general validity, but we can show how some economic systems, namely fisheries and mineral extraction, can be quantitatively described by a simple system dynamics model that has the overshoot character as its basic feature.I documenti in IRIS sono protetti da copyright e tutti i diritti sono riservati, salvo diversa indicazione.


