Humankind faces today a number of fundamental challenges related to its interaction with the planetary ecosystem: climate change, mineral depletion, species extinction, overexploitation of resources and more. As the situation worsens, these challenges appear more and more visible and it is a common opinion that – at some point – a majority of people should recognize the danger and clamour for action against the threat. However, this “bottom-up” approach is failing. For instance, the correlation of climate change with some recent phenomena in the form of large fires and hurricane went unmentioned in the traditional media and generated no new interest in climate change. So, why don’t people react to events that are potentially existential threats for them? The aim of this study is to develop a system dynamics model that can tell us the reasons for this failure. We base our model on the concept of “meme”, a self-replicating unit of information existing in the virtual space, that can be thought as an analogy to the “gene” existing in the biosphere. The virtual space, formed by printed media, broadcast media and the World Wide Web allows the propagation of this unit of information by means a “viral” mechanism, similar to the self-reinforcing mechanism we observe in individuals which infect each others when exposed to a viral flu. In a previous paper, we showed how this mechanism can be simulated with a simple system dynamics model, almost the same used to describe the diffusion of epidemic diseases in medicine. In that article, we assess that initial mechanism that caused memes spreading can go viral, by a bottom-up mechanism generated by interactions among individuals, whereas others were pushed by a top-down effect generated by traditional media. Continuing on the basis of this first study, in the present paper, we analyze the decline of the diffusion of memes as revealed by statistical analysis of the number of Web searches. We find that we can describe this behavior by means of a three stock model where the diffusion occurs in sequence from 1) unaware, 2) active, and 3) quiescent. This sequence for memes is wholly analogous to that known in epidemic studies as 1) sane, 2) infected, and 3) immune. When we compare the model result to the historical data, we find that it can describe the real behavior of memes. The model tells us a very important factor not commonly recognized. The diffusion of a new meme, such as climate change, follows a cycle that leads people to a condition of quiescence where they are immune to acquiring new information. In other words, many people are aware of the danger and the importance of – say – climate change, but they do not react to new information and they do not act on the challenge. The cycle that leads to this situation is self-contained into virtual space and new information (e. g. hurricanes and other climatic disasters) affect it at most as temporary spikes of interest which quickly fade out. The consequence is that it is hopeless to think that some large event or disaster will move the public opinion toward action against climate change. The bottom-up model simply doesn’t work and we need to find new approaches to generate action against climate change and other threats for humankind.
Falsini, S., Perissi, I., Bardi, U. (2019). Why the Bottom-Up Approach Fails with the Challenges Facing Humankind. A System Dynamics Model Study of the Diffusion of Memes in the World Wide Web. In BORDERS WITHOUT BORDERS:Systemic frameworks and their applications for sustainable well-being in the global era BOOK OF ABSTRACTS. Business Systems Laboratory.
Why the Bottom-Up Approach Fails with the Challenges Facing Humankind. A System Dynamics Model Study of the Diffusion of Memes in the World Wide Web
Perissi I;
2019
Abstract
Humankind faces today a number of fundamental challenges related to its interaction with the planetary ecosystem: climate change, mineral depletion, species extinction, overexploitation of resources and more. As the situation worsens, these challenges appear more and more visible and it is a common opinion that – at some point – a majority of people should recognize the danger and clamour for action against the threat. However, this “bottom-up” approach is failing. For instance, the correlation of climate change with some recent phenomena in the form of large fires and hurricane went unmentioned in the traditional media and generated no new interest in climate change. So, why don’t people react to events that are potentially existential threats for them? The aim of this study is to develop a system dynamics model that can tell us the reasons for this failure. We base our model on the concept of “meme”, a self-replicating unit of information existing in the virtual space, that can be thought as an analogy to the “gene” existing in the biosphere. The virtual space, formed by printed media, broadcast media and the World Wide Web allows the propagation of this unit of information by means a “viral” mechanism, similar to the self-reinforcing mechanism we observe in individuals which infect each others when exposed to a viral flu. In a previous paper, we showed how this mechanism can be simulated with a simple system dynamics model, almost the same used to describe the diffusion of epidemic diseases in medicine. In that article, we assess that initial mechanism that caused memes spreading can go viral, by a bottom-up mechanism generated by interactions among individuals, whereas others were pushed by a top-down effect generated by traditional media. Continuing on the basis of this first study, in the present paper, we analyze the decline of the diffusion of memes as revealed by statistical analysis of the number of Web searches. We find that we can describe this behavior by means of a three stock model where the diffusion occurs in sequence from 1) unaware, 2) active, and 3) quiescent. This sequence for memes is wholly analogous to that known in epidemic studies as 1) sane, 2) infected, and 3) immune. When we compare the model result to the historical data, we find that it can describe the real behavior of memes. The model tells us a very important factor not commonly recognized. The diffusion of a new meme, such as climate change, follows a cycle that leads people to a condition of quiescence where they are immune to acquiring new information. In other words, many people are aware of the danger and the importance of – say – climate change, but they do not react to new information and they do not act on the challenge. The cycle that leads to this situation is self-contained into virtual space and new information (e. g. hurricanes and other climatic disasters) affect it at most as temporary spikes of interest which quickly fade out. The consequence is that it is hopeless to think that some large event or disaster will move the public opinion toward action against climate change. The bottom-up model simply doesn’t work and we need to find new approaches to generate action against climate change and other threats for humankind.I documenti in IRIS sono protetti da copyright e tutti i diritti sono riservati, salvo diversa indicazione.


