Pegzilarginase in Arginase 1 Deficiency: Clinical and Biochemical Effects of Treatment Initiation, Discontinuation and Re-Initiation

Background: Arginase 1 deficiency (ARG1-D) is an ultra-rare urea cycle disorder characterized by hyperargininemia and progressive neurological impairment, including spasticity, loss of motor function, and reduced quality of life. Conventional management based on dietary protein restriction and ammonia scavengers rarely achieves adequate metabolic control or prevents neurological deterioration. Pegzilarginase, a recombinant human arginase 1 enzyme, is the first disease-modifying therapy for ARG1-D. Methods: We report the first Italian real-world experience with pegzilarginase in three pediatric patients with genetically confirmed ARG1-D enrolled in the phase 3 PEACE trial. Clinical, biochemical, functional, nutritional and quality-of-life data were retrospectively collected over a long-term follow-up (2003–2025). Outcomes were evaluated across three phases: treatment initiation (Start), a 13-month treatment interruption due to trial closure (Stop), and therapy re-initiation through an early access program (Restart). Results: Pegzilarginase rapidly normalized plasma arginine levels and was associated with improvements in motor function, spasticity, walking endurance, dietary protein tolerance, bone mineral density, and quality of life. During treatment interruption, all patients experienced biochemical worsening and clinical deterioration, including increased spasticity, reduced mobility, and emotional distress. Re-initiation of pegzilarginase restored metabolic control and led to progressive neurological and functional recovery, including partial reversal of long-standing motor deficits. Conclusions: This real-world experience supports pegzilarginase as a disease-modifying therapy for ARG1-D. Sustained normalization of plasma arginine, rather than subthreshold biochemical control, correlates with functional and neurological improvement and may partially reverse non-lesional metabolic brain injury. Early initiation of pegzilarginase, including in newborn-screened patients, may further modify the natural history of ARG1-D.