The two faces of the same medal… or maybe not? Comparing osteoarthritis and calcium pyrophosphate deposition disease: A laboratory and ultrasonographic study

Objective Osteoarthritis (OA) and calcium pyrophosphate deposition disease (CPPD) are frequently associated but the real relation between these diseases is not still understood. The aim of this paper is to investigate the characteristics in terms of inflammation, anatomical changes and synovial fluid (SF) features in knees of patients with OA and CPPD. Methods Consecutive patients older than 55 years with knee pain and swelling were enrolled. All patients underwent a complete clinical examination, a US examination of the affected joint, arthrocentesis of the knee and analysis of synovial fluid, including dosing of inorganic ions and number of crystals. The gold standard for the diagnosis was the microscopic analysis of the SF. Results Sixty-seven patients were enrolled, 25 affected by OA and 42 by CPPD. At US, a significantly higher amount of effusion and synovitis was identified in patients with CPPD but there were no significant differences regarding structural changes. At the SF analysis, the white blood cell (WBC) count was higher in patients with CPPD who also presented a higher number of polymorphonuclear cells and a lower number of monocytes. Regarding the inorganic ion concentration, the statistical analysis did not reveal any differences. The number of crystals in the SF, correlated with a larger effusion, higher grade of synovitis and a higher WBC count. Conclusion A higher degree of inflammation was found in patients with CPPD. The findings suggest that longitudinal studies would be useful to better understand the evolution of the diseases and highlight the need for different treatment strategies.