This thesis focuses on the social relationships constituting domestic water management and the use of spring water for irrigation, in the rural village of Wādī Fūkīn (West Bank). It investigates how the dialectics between power strategies exerted through water policies and local resistance practices contribute to define the meaning of community, state and citizenship. The Israeli and the Palestinian National Authority (PNA)’s projects of water modernisation and the intensive farming and irrigation techniques fostered by development actors emerge as techno-politics aimed at creating colonial subjects, farmers or citizens. The analysis of the Israeli water and territory planning brings insights into the theorisation of technical planning as a new dimension of politics of the modern-state. As a response to the Israeli strategies of de-peasantisation and land expropriation, villagers view farming activities as practices of self-representation against the threat of becoming refugees. The study highlights the role of water in the Israeli and Palestinian nation-state construction. The Israeli and the PNA’s ideological constructions of water scarcity – shown as a hybrid socio-natural process – are aimed at ensuring conflicting interests, while legitimising multiple dynamics of domination. Local practices of resistance to the PNA’s water centralisation bring to light that domestic water is a political arena in which the meaning of state and its legitimacy are contested and negotiated between the political elites ruling the PNA, Israel and other local interest groups. The local spring water management reveals that this resource mediates the construction of local dimensions of identification and differentiation shaping the tribal political organisation, which emerges as an idiom of solidarity to struggle for self-determination. This study addresses the important debate about the relationships between the State and tribal political patterns. The adoption of intensive irrigation and farming techniques has contributed to the individualisation of farming and resistance strategies. Donors’ interventions have led to the de-mobilisation of the local community and to the emergence of a new “globalized elite”, amplifying dynamics of marginalisation, in particular of women. Local farmers express their claims for autonomy and socio-ecological justice by means of the embodiment of alternative patterns of water and farming knowledge. However, in daily practices the intensive farming techniques and the local ones are juxtaposed and articulated, leading to the production of a sort of “hybrid agriculture”. The Palestinian territories are fragmented in different hydro-social networks and territories, in multiple “islands of experience” characterised by different conditions of water stress and experiences of deprivation. This leads to the imagination of multiple Palestinian nations and Palestinian “others”.

(2018). Spring Water: the Lifeblood of the Village of Wādī Fūkīn (West Bank). (Tesi di dottorato, Università degli Studi di Milano-Bicocca, 2018).

Spring Water: the Lifeblood of the Village of Wādī Fūkīn (West Bank)

DE DONATO, ANITA
2018

Abstract

This thesis focuses on the social relationships constituting domestic water management and the use of spring water for irrigation, in the rural village of Wādī Fūkīn (West Bank). It investigates how the dialectics between power strategies exerted through water policies and local resistance practices contribute to define the meaning of community, state and citizenship. The Israeli and the Palestinian National Authority (PNA)’s projects of water modernisation and the intensive farming and irrigation techniques fostered by development actors emerge as techno-politics aimed at creating colonial subjects, farmers or citizens. The analysis of the Israeli water and territory planning brings insights into the theorisation of technical planning as a new dimension of politics of the modern-state. As a response to the Israeli strategies of de-peasantisation and land expropriation, villagers view farming activities as practices of self-representation against the threat of becoming refugees. The study highlights the role of water in the Israeli and Palestinian nation-state construction. The Israeli and the PNA’s ideological constructions of water scarcity – shown as a hybrid socio-natural process – are aimed at ensuring conflicting interests, while legitimising multiple dynamics of domination. Local practices of resistance to the PNA’s water centralisation bring to light that domestic water is a political arena in which the meaning of state and its legitimacy are contested and negotiated between the political elites ruling the PNA, Israel and other local interest groups. The local spring water management reveals that this resource mediates the construction of local dimensions of identification and differentiation shaping the tribal political organisation, which emerges as an idiom of solidarity to struggle for self-determination. This study addresses the important debate about the relationships between the State and tribal political patterns. The adoption of intensive irrigation and farming techniques has contributed to the individualisation of farming and resistance strategies. Donors’ interventions have led to the de-mobilisation of the local community and to the emergence of a new “globalized elite”, amplifying dynamics of marginalisation, in particular of women. Local farmers express their claims for autonomy and socio-ecological justice by means of the embodiment of alternative patterns of water and farming knowledge. However, in daily practices the intensive farming techniques and the local ones are juxtaposed and articulated, leading to the production of a sort of “hybrid agriculture”. The Palestinian territories are fragmented in different hydro-social networks and territories, in multiple “islands of experience” characterised by different conditions of water stress and experiences of deprivation. This leads to the imagination of multiple Palestinian nations and Palestinian “others”.
VAN AKEN, MAURO IVO
CASCIARRI, BARBARA
Water; West Bank; Nation-state; Tribalism; Agriculture
M-DEA/01 - DISCIPLINE DEMOETNOANTROPOLOGICHE
English
29-ott-2018
ANTROPOLOGIA DELLA CONTEMPORANEITA': ETNOGRAFIA DELLE DIVERSITA' E DELLE CONVERGENZE CULTURALI - 40R
28
2015/2016
PARIS 8 UNIVERSITY - UNIVERSITÉ PARIS 8 VINCENNES IN SAINT-DENIS
open
(2018). Spring Water: the Lifeblood of the Village of Wādī Fūkīn (West Bank). (Tesi di dottorato, Università degli Studi di Milano-Bicocca, 2018).
File in questo prodotto:
File Dimensione Formato  
phd_unimib_042178.pdf

accesso aperto

Descrizione: Tesi dottorato
Tipologia di allegato: Doctoral thesis
Dimensione 31.75 MB
Formato Adobe PDF
31.75 MB Adobe PDF Visualizza/Apri

I documenti in IRIS sono protetti da copyright e tutti i diritti sono riservati, salvo diversa indicazione.

Utilizza questo identificativo per citare o creare un link a questo documento: https://hdl.handle.net/10281/205801
Citazioni
  • Scopus ND
  • ???jsp.display-item.citation.isi??? ND
Social impact